Should You Fly Icelandair?

The Professor's Experiences May Help Your Decision

Author: The Traveling Professor/Friday, June 24, 2016/Categories: Norway/Iceland/Denmark

Rate this article:

Icelandair is a low-cost carrier serving 16 North American airports.  All flights from North America go through Iceland's Keflavik airport on their way to over 40 destinations in Europe.  I have been on several Icelandair flights in the past year as well as many of our Traveling Professor travelers on our small group tours to Iceland.  In this blog post I will relay to you my personal experiences with and opinions of Icelandair.

What I Like About Icelandair

Prices:  Icelandair offers some of the most competitive fares to Iceland and the rest of Europe.  It is not unusual to find coach fares under $1,000 any time of the year, including peak summer season.  Excellent fares can be found for Economy Comfort and other premium seats, often at a lower price than flying coach on other legacy carriers to Europe.

Stopover:  Every flight from North America stops in Keflavik airport in Iceland before going onward to any destination in Europe.  Travelers can stay in Iceland for up to 7 days at no additional charge upon going forward to other European destinations.  Travelers can also stopover on their return.

Flight Crew:  Professional, courteous, and helpful.  They are professionally dressed and do their jobs promptly and efficiently.

Equipment:  My experience has been on the Boeing 757 although I understand the 767 is in service or will soon be.  I found the planes to be clean and in good condition.

Loyalty Program:  Saga Club members accumulate points towards elite status, flights, and upgrades.  Points can be used to purchase meals and other items.

Lounge:  Those with access to lounges will find a full-featured comfortable Saga Club lounge.

In-Flight Entertainment:  Free access to a good choice of movies, TV programs, and other programming.

What I Don't Like So Much About Icelandair

Equipment: My experience is in taking the 757-200 between North America and Iceland.  It has a 3 x 3 across configuration in most coach rows.  I doubt any Icelandair executive has flown in economy class because they would realize how much they are torturing their passengers.  Seats are very uncomfortable, way too tight, and a misery on an overnight flight to Iceland.  My biggest dislike about Icelandair is the uncomfortable Economy Class seating.   However, if you want to pay for it, Economy Comfort and Saga Class may be worth it.  But that's why they make Economy class so uncomfortable, who would pay to upgrade if they didn't make it an agonizing experience?   If anyone at Icelandair disagrees, I will bet they never flew on a full flight in row 28, seat B (middle) from JFK to KEF.

However, my experience on the flights between Iceland and the rest of Europe is better.  More room and more comfort with the seating.

Customer Service:  My personal experience has been waits of 20 minutes or more when phoning customer service to change flights or to ask other travel related questions.  In another instance when I checked in at the Boston airport, I was invited to use the lounge by the Icleandair employee checking me in.  When I appeared at the lounge, I was quite embarrassed when I was denied entry.   At the Keflavik airport, while waiting to board our flight, we were herded into groups from one location to another with no explanation for delays or why we needed to go from one area to another.  Because of the lack of organization by Icelandair, a mob mentality took over as passengers cut lines and pushed and shoved while boarding. 

 I am always amazed how airlines "don't get" customer service.  For such little effort they could get so much better returns.  On our Traveling Professor tours, we always treat every customer as special.  I wish I could find an airline that does so also.

Loyalty Program:  There is no "status match" as offered by many other airlines.   For instance, those who hold Platinum elite status on American Airlines for instance, can apply for a parallel service match on other airlines like Delta.  No deal on Icleandair.

In-Flight Meals:  They ALL need to be paid for, even on transcontinental flights.  My experience on American is that they will do TWO meal services, included in the price of the ticket, on overseas flights to Europe.

Change Fees:  This is where Icleandair could distinguish itself but doesn't.  After waiting on the phone, they are still going to charge you like all the other airlines outrageous fees to change your ticket.  I recently paid $200 just to change to an earlier flight back from Iceland to Boston.

Get On The Professor's Mailing List

* indicates required

Number of views (1293)/Comments ()

«January 2020»

Who Traveled With Us in 2019

who travels with The Traveling ProfessorThe Traveling Professor ran small group tours to Iceland, Peru and Machu Picchu, Scotland, Croatia, Italy, Normandy Invasion Beaches, and Canada in 2019.  We had a wonderful year, making new friends and traveling to great places.  But who goes on Traveling Professor tours?  In this blog post, we will tell you the number of people and what the make-up of our small group tours looks like.
Read more

26 Places to Eat in Paris

where to eat in ParisAh, we love to eat when we go on our small group tours to Paris.  Who doesn't?  The Professor presents his list of Paris restaurants. The list includes places for breakfast, lunch, dinner and snacks.  Some are expensive, some are not.  Some qualify as a great place for a romantic dinner, but most of them are on the casual side. Take advantage of The Professor's experience and see where to eat in Pars. 
Read more

The Perfect 14 Day Introduction to Italy Itinerary

perfect 14 day Italy itineraryEveryone loves Italy.  The Traveling Professor's small group tours to Italy usually covers Venice, Florence, Rome and Sorrento (the Amalfi Coast).  Planning an itinerary can be daunting, but The Traveling Professor makes it easy for the first-time Italy traveler.  See all the great sites, eat wonderful food, experience the culture. Take a look at our introduction to Italy itinerary and get ready to say "Ciao!" to Italy.
Read more

A Visit with Vincent Van Gogh in Auvers

Day trip to Auvers from Paris

Vincent Van Gogh is considered by many to be the greatest painter of all time. He spent much of his time in France.  Those who have gone to Paris with The Traveling Professor on one of his small group tours to Paris can remember walking the neighborhoods frequented by Van Gogh and seeing his paintings at the Musee d'Orsay. In today's guest blog post adapted from a  post originally done by Laura Keefe Junod of, she talks about visiting Auvers - the place where Van Gogh lived, died and is buried. She does a wonderful job of explaining where Van Gogh  lived, died and is buried.

Read more

What to Do in Paris the 2nd Time You Go

what to see 2nd time in ParisThe Eiffel Tower, the Musée d'Orsay, Louvre, Montmartre, Seine River Cruise, Pantheon, Pomidou Center, Rodin Museum, Arc de Triomphe - those are all things people see on their first trip to Paris.  They are timeless sites that probably could be visited time and time again. But what should you see on your second and even third or fourth visit to Paris. In this blog, The Traveling Professor gives some ideas on other great sites that would be superstars in nearly any other place in the world. 
Read more